Bartelsmeyer Jewelry Services

Goldsmith/Custom Design

John Bartelsmeyer has over 40 years of experience in creating and restoring fine jewelry. Express your ideas and desires for the special item you have in mind, and then John will assist you with creating a unique one-of-a–kind piece of jewelry.


Add a personal touch to silver charms, baby cups, silver-plated trays, picture frames and many other gifts and jewelry items. We have an in-house engraver allowing quick delivery of the finished product.


We offer appraisal services for insurance replacement and estate evaluations. The Gem Appraisal System is our appraisal standard. We can assist our customers with identifying costume jewelry versus fine jewelry at no charge. Please call for an appointment.

Watch Repair

We offer all types of watch services from antique watch restoration to the most modern, high-tech time pieces. Energy cell (Battery) replacement for most models is available while you wait.

Cleaning and Inspection

Cleaning and inspection of your fine jewelry while you wait is available at no charge. If requested, items are polished to a near new appearance for a small fee.

Complimentary Gift Wrapping

Gift wrapping for purchases is always available at no charge. When customers see the Bartelsmeyer sticker on their package, they know they are receiving a very special gift!

We Buy Precious Metals, Gem Stones, and Estate Jewelry

Turn your broken, outdated, unwanted jewelry into cash! We buy gold, silver, or platinum, gemstones, and estate jewelry. We can tell you what your jewelry is worth in today’s market and make an offer to purchase it. We will buy your estate jewelry, whether you have one piece or one hundred pieces. We buy diamonds, and other precious gem stones too. You can trade your old jewelry toward a beautiful new piece. We can also help you determine whether the old box of grandmother’s jewelry is costume or precious metal. Don't throw away your old or broken costume jewelry. We can help you find people who purchase costume jewelry.

Special Orders

Let us help you find the gift you are searching for. We have over 50 years of experience in locating items that are difficult to obtain! We will contact our vendors to help fill a special order for your once-in-a-lifetime occasion.

Layaway Program

Convenient interest-free layaway plans are always available at Bartelsmeyer Jewelry with a 20% deposit and consistent monthly payments.

Finance Program

Ninety days interest-free financing. Customers are approved within 24 hours online without submitting paystubs or bank statements. Minimum qualifications: cell phone number, email address, credit score minimum of 500, checking account in good standing for at least 90 days, and minimum gross monthly income of $1000. Minimum amount financed is $350. Monthly/semi-monthly payments are affordable with no pre-payment penalties.